The Ultimate Martin D18: History & Comparison

We compare five Martin D18s. Built from 1937 to 2025. Watch and listen to these rare and special guitars here.
March 31, 2025 by
Jurgen Bakker
| No comments yet

History of the D18

Style 18

Decades before the world was introduced to the dreadnought, Martin introduced their number system to indicate materials and degree of decoration. The ‘18-style’ is named after the price tag of those instruments: $18.


In addition, the 18-style did not originally have mahogany, but rosewood back and sides. This changed in 1917. Style 18 switched to mahogany, and the 28-style got rosewood.

Origin of the dreadnought

Like many developments in guitar history, the dreadnought is also the result of the quest for more volume. These instruments were designed to produce more projection and bass.


The very first dreadnought-sized guitars were not Martin guitars, but they were produced by Martin. How that could be? Martin produced these guitars for the Oliver Ditson Company from 1916 onwards. For example, the ‘111 model’ pictured here. The 111 model has mahogany back and sides, a 12-fret neck and a slotted headstock.

The D18 of Martin

In 1931, Martin started producing the dreadnought under their own name. Like the Ditson models, this dreadnought had a 12-fret neck. In 1934, Martin introduced the 14-fret version of the D18, which became the modern standard. Besides the new neck, the body got its distinctive 'square' shoulders and also the headstock is as we know it today.


With its mahogany construction, the D18 was positioned as a more affordable alternative to the top-of-the-range D28, which made it especially popular during the Great Depression. The guitar's dry, punchy tone and light weight attracted musicians looking for clarity and projection without too much embellishment. Over the years, the D18 became a favourite among singer-songwriters and flatpickers because of its balanced sound and midrange. Indeed, this fits well between bass instruments and the higher notes of instruments such as mandolins.


One of the rarest versions is the 1937 D18 with a ‘shaded top’; a top with a sunburst finish. Only a few were made, making it a sought-after collector's item today.

1850s
Beginning of ‘number-style’ system​

Style 18 originally has rosewood back and sides.

1917
From rosewood to mahogany

Style 18 gets mahogany back and sides.

1931

Martin takes over production of the dreadnought.

1934

Introduction of the 14-fret dreadnought.

1937
The Shaded Top

Martin makes a limited quantity of D18s with a ‘shaded top’ sunburst finish.

Specs Evolution

Bracing

Before 1939, the D18 had forward-shifted X-bracing, which allowed for greater movement of the top and resulted in a warm, open tone with a strong bass response. In 1939, Martin moved the bracing back slightly, giving the D18 a more tight sound and more focus in the midrange. 


Another major change occurred in 1944 when Martin replaced scalloped bracing with non-scalloped bracing to increase production efficiency. While scalloped bracing provided a more resonant and dynamic sound, non-scalloped bracing gave the guitar a tighter, more articulate tone that could cut through a mix more effectively.


Pre-1939
Forward-Shifted Bracing

More bass response, open resonance, warm low end.

Post-1939
Rear-Shifted Bracing

 Tighter sound, more midrange focus, less boominess.

Pre-1944
Scalloped Bracing

More resonance, scooped mids, rich bass & treble.

Post-1944
Non-Scalloped Bracing

More midrange-focused, tighter, and articulate, making it better for cutting through a mix in band settings.

1944-1949
Tapered Bracing

The transition to non-scalloped bracing was gradual from 1944 to 1949. 

Neck

Before 1944, the D18 used a steel T-bar to reinforce the neck, which provided excellent sustain and structural rigidity. However, due to wartime metal shortages, Martin briefly replaced the steel bar with a lighter ebony bar in 1944, which gave the guitar a woodier, warmer tone, but at the expense of neck stability. In 1946, Martin switched back to a steel T-bar.


The neck profile also changed over the years, from a solid V-shape in the 1930s to a softer V or rounded profile in the 1940s and 1950s. By the 1960s, Martin opted for a slimmer C-shaped neck for better playability, to meet the preferences of modern players.


Mystery Tops

One of the more intriguing quirks in the history of the D18 are the so-called “Mystery Tops” from the 1950s. While Sitka spruce was the standard top wood, some D18s from that era have tops with grain patterns that do not match the typical Sitka characteristics. These variations suggest that Martin used a mix of Sitka, Adirondack or even Engelmann spruce. This was possibly due to material shortages or leftovers from previous decades. Because these guitars have unique visual and tonal characteristics, they are highly sought after by collectors.

1930s
V-shaped Neck

The V-shaped neck is thicker and fuller than its successors.

1940/50s
Soft V-shaped Neck

The Soft V, or rounder, profile is slightly slimmer.

Pre-1944
Steel T-Bar

 Good sustain, clear tone, and stable but no truss rodd.

1944
Tuning Machines

Celluloid tuners due to metal shortages.

Ebony Rod

Lighter, warmer, woodier tone, but less structural support.

Post-1946
Steel T-bar

More rigid, common in post-war models.

 From 1960
C-shaped Neck

Slimmer necks with more C-shape. Designed for easier playability.

Ultimate Vintage Martin D18 Shootout

Watch our vintage Martin D18 comparison video here.

Featuring demos by one of the best acoustic guitarists in the Netherlands: Bertolf! 


Flatpicking Comparison

Fingerstyle Comparison

Guitars From The Video

1937: Shaded Top

Top: Adirondack

Neck Reinforcement: Steel T-Bar

Bracing: Forward Shifted, Scalloped

Listen To Bertolf's Demo

1940

Top: Adirondack

Neck Reinforcement: Steel T-Bar

Bracing: Rear Shifted, Scalloped

Listen To Bertolf's Demo

1944

Top: Adirondack

Neck Reinforcement: Ebbenhout 

Bracing: Rear Shifted, Scalloped

Listen To Bertolf's Demo

1949

Bovenblad: Sitka Spar 

Neck Reinforcement: Steel T-Bar

Bracing: Rear Shifted, Tapered 

Listen To Bertolf's Demo

1953: Mystery Top

Top: Adirondack 

Neck Reinforcement: Steel T-Bar

Bracing: Rear Shifted, Non-Scalloped

Listen To Bertolf's Demo

2025: Authentic 1937

Top: Adirondack 

Bracing: Forward Shifted, Scalloped

See It Here

Want to see more vintage guitars?

Then be sure to check out our wide selection!

Sign in to leave a comment